Assessing Pre-Clinical Medical Students’ Knowledge and Attitudes Toward High-Value Care

From the 2024 HVPA National Conference

Zoe Matticks MPH (UC San Diego), Harmonie Strohl BA, Matthew Allen BS, Kelsey Smith BA, Gregory Seymann MD

Background:
Despite a national focus on increasing value in healthcare through improved quality and better resource stewardship, high-value care (HVC) curricula has been more slowly adopted in undergraduate medical education compared to graduate medical education or early career training.1,2 AAMC guidelines state that graduating medical students should gain HVC competencies such as cost-awareness and pre- and post-test diagnostic probability, yet our experiences and the literature emphasize that medical education has not yet fulfilled this guideline.3,4

UC San Diego School of Medicine offers two preclinical courses with learning objectives that include HVC concepts: a 2-year longitudinal thread and 3-month elective. Assessing the baseline attitudes and knowledge of HVC in matriculating medical students will allow us to measure how existing curricula shape students’ attitudes and knowledge. The results may also serve to substantiate the concern that HVC concepts may not be adequately represented in preclinical medical school curriculum, highlighting the potential need for increased efforts.

Objective:
How do medical student attitudes towards HVC change during the preclinical curriculum at UC San Diego School of Medicine overall and among students that take the Volume to Value HVC elective?

Methods:
We used the Maastricht HVCCC Attitude Questionnaire (MHAQ) to evaluate first-year medical students at UC San Diego School of Medicine prior to exposure to HVC curriculum in the first year of medical school; the MHAQ includes a set of validated measures to evaluate the attitudes of various stakeholders towards High-Value, Cost-Conscious Care (HVCCC).5 A second evaluation, administered in May 2024, will utilize the same validated measures in a post-exposure survey. A paired t-test will compare the pre and post- survey results.

We will use the survey results to assess how existing curricular elements and extracurricular opportunities facilitate competencies in HVC concepts. Results may also help facilitate dialogue with UC San Diego School of Medicine administration about how best to develop HVC curricula for future students.

Interim Results:
Results from the baseline survey administered in September-October 2023 included a total of 27 MS1 students, 78% of whom identified as cis-gender women. Students were interested in a broad selection of medical specialties, with Internal Medicine, OBGYN, and Family Medicine most selected. Results of the MHAQ suggest that students agree with the concepts of High Value Care and are neutral when considering drawbacks of value-based care methods (Figure 1). Students also tend to agree that cost-effectiveness should be considered in treatment decisions.

Discussion & Conclusion:
Our second survey will be distributed in May 2024, with analysis to follow. We will measure trends in HVCCC attitudes across the academic year, and any associations to engagement in the standard vs additional HVC exposure via participation in the HVC elective course or a set of defined extracurricular activities.

The study will measure any additional benefit of the elective course and extracurricular opportunities in tandem with the updated standard preclinical curriculum to discern changes in attitudes or knowledge. Ultimately, this study will help in developing curricula that can improve medical students’ understanding of and attitudes towards high-value care. This project will inform future HVC curricular interventions to help medical students develop the skills necessary to promote effective resource-stewardship and high quality patient care.